Formulas, sources and changelog
Every route is simulated month by month over the same time frame, and its cost is the interest and fees it costs you. Penalties use each lender's published method through the shared MITEY engine. This page lists every formula, rule and estimate with its source and checked date, plus a dated changelog.
Figures as of 2026-11-01.
| Mortgage | $250,000 at 5.25%, current-rate lender, 38 months left, 20 years |
|---|---|
| Stay: interest over 5 years | $57,296 |
| Break: penalty + fees | $7,304 |
| Break: interest over 5 years | $52,088 |
| Break cost = interest + penalty + fees | $59,392vs $57,296 to stay |
Open this example in the calculator →Computed by this site's engine with the defaults and sources shown on the methodology page.Computed 2026-11-01.
How does the refinance model work?
Each route is simulated month by month over the same time frame (by default, the new term). Its cost is:
upfront cash + payments made + balance owed at the end − balance owed today − cash taken out
That is exactly the interest and fees the route costs, whether fees are paid in cash or added to the loan. The lowest cost leaves you with the most at the end. We don't credit interest you could earn by investing a payment difference.
Which formulas does the engine use?
- Three months' interest = amount prepaid × your rate ÷ 12 × 3.
- IRD = (your rate − comparison rate) × amount prepaid × years left, not discounted to present value. Posted-rate method: comparison = posted rate for the time left − (posted rate when you signed − your rate). Current-rate method: comparison = the lender's current rate for the time left.
- Penalty: closed fixed = the higher of the two; closed variable = three months' interest. A prepayment privilege comes off the balance first.
- Posted rate for the time left: read on a straight line between the Bank of Canada's typical posted 1-, 3- and 5-year rates. Posted rate when you signed: the typical posted 5-year rate that month.
- Blended rate = (your rate × months left + new rate × extra months) ÷ new term in months; with cash out, the new money is at the new rate.
- Payments: level monthly payments, semi-annual compounding for fixed mortgages (Interest Act), monthly for variable mortgages; the payment is recomputed over the amortization left when a term renews.
- HELOC: interest-only at prime + 0.5. Limits: total ≤ 80% of value; HELOC ≤ 65%.
- Qualifying rate = max(new rate + 2, 5.25)%. Break-even month: first month the refinance's cost so far is at or below staying's. Rate you'd need: the new rate at which both cost the same, by bisection.
Which rules and estimates does it use?
| Item | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Months of interest in the usual minimum prepayment penalty (FCAC) | 3 | Financial Consumer Agency of Canada |
| Interest Act s. 10: on a mortgage whose term is longer than this many months, once this many months have passed the charge is at most 3 months' interest | 60 | Justice Laws |
| Closed variable mortgages: 3 months' interest, no IRD (RBC and TD; most lenders work the same way) | true | RBC Royal Bank |
| Most a federally regulated lender can lend against a home without mortgage insurance, all mortgages combined (Bank Act s. 418) | 0.8 | Justice Laws |
| Most the revolving (HELOC) part can be, as a share of value (OSFI B-20) | 0.65 | OSFI |
| Low-ratio (portfolio-insured) straight switch: the balance may rise by up to this much to cover switching costs ($). Uninsured straight switches allow no increase in the loan amount. | $3,000 | Department of Finance Canada |
| Qualifying-rate buffer over the contract rate (percentage points) | 2 | OSFI |
| Qualifying-rate floor (%) | 5.25 | OSFI |
| Housing costs as a share of gross income (CMHC's limit; many lenders use it for uninsured loans too) | 39 | CMHC |
| All debt payments as a share of gross income (CMHC's limit) | 44 | CMHC |
| Days before the term ends that a federally regulated lender must send your renewal statement | 21 | Financial Consumer Agency of Canada |
| Big-bank prime rate after the Bank of Canada raised its policy rate to 2.50% on October 29, 2026 (%) | 4.7 | Bank of Canada |
| HELOC rate over prime we use as a default (percentage points; offers vary) | 0.5 | Our estimate |
| Appraisal fee ($); quotes vary by city, property and appraiser | $450 | Our estimate |
| Lawyer or notary and registration on a refinance or new HELOC ($); some lenders pay part or all | $1,200 | Our estimate |
| Discharge or transfer fee your current lender charges when you leave ($) | $350 | Our estimate |
| Administration fee for a blend-and-extend ($); many lenders charge less or nothing | $250 | Our estimate |
What has changed, and when?
- 2026-11-01: Penalty estimates now use each listed lender's published method (comparison term, posted-rate discount, present value where the lender says so) through the shared MITEY penalty engine, with a cash-back clawback input. Results are labelled as estimates.
- 2026-11-01: Added a stress-test check (income, debts, property tax, heating, condo fees) using the shared MITEY qualification engine.
- 2026-11-01: Corrected the straight-switch rule: an uninsured straight switch allows no increase to the loan amount (OSFI); the up-to-$3,000 allowance for costs applies to low-ratio portfolio-insured switches (Department of Finance, December 16, 2024). OSFI doesn't expect lenders to apply the qualifying rate, but a lender may still requalify you.
- 2026-11-01: Fixed the cash-out verdict when no route fits within the 80% limit (it now shows the maximum you could raise) and the at-renewal state when no time is left on the term.
- 2026-11-01: Site launched on the MITEY site kit around one decision: break your mortgage and refinance now, blend and extend, add a HELOC, or wait for renewal. Penalty methods checked against FCAC, RBC and TD; refinance limits against the Bank Act and OSFI B-20; the qualifying rate against OSFI. Savings are measured in interest and fees over the same time frame.
- 2026-10-29: Bank of Canada policy rate rose from 2.25% to 2.50%; big-bank prime moved to 4.70%.
Where does every fact come from?
Primary sources (checked dates shown)
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada — Reduce mortgage prepayment penalties (3 months' interest or the IRD; posted-rate method; prepayment privileges; porting) (effective October 15, 2025). Checked .
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada — Breaking your mortgage contract (fees, cash-back clawback, blend-and-extend) (effective October 15, 2025). Checked .
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada — Renewing your mortgage (21-day renewal statement; switching costs) (effective October 15, 2025). Checked .
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada — Borrowing money using home equity (80% / 65% limits, fees, risk to your home) (effective October 15, 2025). Checked .
- RBC Royal Bank — Understanding mortgage prepayment charges (posted rate less your rate reduction; present value). Checked .
- TD — TD explains: what is an IRD? (posted rate for a similar mortgage minus your discount) (effective August 19, 2020). Checked .
- Justice Laws — Bank Act, s. 418: 80% limit on uninsured residential loans (including refinances) (effective September 1, 2026). Checked .
- OSFI — Guideline B-20: Residential mortgage underwriting (HELOC limit 65% of value) (effective October 31, 2017). Checked .
- OSFI — Minimum qualifying rate for uninsured mortgages (contract + 2 points or 5.25%) (effective January 29, 2026). Checked .
- OSFI — Uninsured straight switches exempt from the minimum qualifying rate (no increase to the amortization or the loan amount) (effective November 21, 2024). Checked .
- Department of Finance Canada — Straight switches and portfolio insurance (low-ratio insured switches; up to $3,000 for costs) (effective December 16, 2024). Checked .
- Justice Laws — Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations (SOR/2012-281), s. 6.1: insured refinance to add housing units (effective January 15, 2025). Checked .
- CMHC — Calculating GDS / TDS (39% / 44%). Checked .
- Justice Laws — Interest Act, ss. 6 and 10 (rates stated yearly or half-yearly; on terms over 5 years, 3 months' interest after 5 years). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Target for the overnight rate (series V39079): 2.50% from October 29, 2026 (effective October 29, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Posted conventional mortgage rate, 1-year (series V80691333) (effective November 4, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Posted conventional mortgage rate, 3-year (series V80691334) (effective November 4, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Posted conventional mortgage rate, 5-year (series V80691335) (effective November 4, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Effective rate on new uninsured fixed mortgages, 5 years and over (series V122667786) (effective August 1, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Effective rate on new uninsured fixed mortgages, 1 to <3 years (series V122667784) (effective August 1, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Effective rate on outstanding credit card balances (series V122667812) (effective August 1, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Effective rate on new unsecured personal lines of credit (series V122667807) (effective August 1, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Effective rate on new personal loan plans (series V122667804) (effective August 1, 2026). Checked .
- Bank of Canada — Effective rate on new auto loans (personal loan plans) (series V122667805) (effective August 1, 2026). Checked .